The Trouble with Person Centered Planning

This thought-provoking document, “The Trouble With Person-Centered Planning” by John O’Brien, dives deep into the challenges and transformative potential of person-centered planning. ​ It explores how this approach, when practiced authentically, can awaken a shared sense of purpose, dignity, and interdependence among people. ​ However, the trouble lies in its collision with system rationality—bureaucratic structures that prioritize efficiency, rules, and impersonal processes over genuine human connection. ​ O’Brien contrasts the lifeworld rationality, rooted in mutual care and relationships, with the system rationality that often colonizes spaces meant for creativity and inclusion. ​

The document highlights the tension between the ideals of person-centered planning—self-direction, inclusion, and meaningful contribution—and the limitations of current service structures, which often fall short of delivering on these promises. ​ It emphasizes the importance of transcending system boundaries to create spaces where people can connect, affirm each other’s gifts, and act collectively toward a better future. ​

Lyle Romer’s response enriches the discussion, reflecting on the historical missteps of rigid planning and the enduring power of human relationships. He argues that the essence of person-centered planning lies not in manuals or techniques but in the music of human connection—the bonds that inspire action and understanding.

This document challenges readers to rethink how we support one another in a systematized world, urging us to protect and expand spaces for authentic encounters. ​ It’s a call to embrace the wonder of human interdependence and resist the veil of indifference, making room for creativity, inclusion, and shared purpose. ​ Perfect for anyone passionate about social justice, disability advocacy, or community building, this is a must-read for those seeking to make a meaningful impact. ​