This insightful document, Surviving Cogworld? Supporting People with Developmental Disabilities in a Mechanistic System by John O’Brien, explores the challenges of balancing relationships and transactions in systems designed to support people with developmental disabilities. It critiques the growing mechanization of care, dubbed “Cogworld,” where assistance is treated as a series of tasks rather than a foundation for meaningful relationships. O’Brien argues that good support is rooted in relationships that respect dignity, foster growth, and enable active citizenship, rather than rigid compliance with bureaucratic rules.
The paper highlights the shift in U.S. long-term care systems, where cost control and standardization often overshadow personalized, relationship-based support. It warns against the risks of reducing care to technical transactions, which can alienate individuals and demoralize caregivers. Instead, O’Brien advocates for a “story of balance,” emphasizing tailored supports, community inclusion, and the importance of co-creating solutions with families, allies, and caregivers.
Readers will find thought-provoking insights on how systemic pressures, such as funding constraints and regulatory demands, impact the quality of care. The document calls for innovative approaches to meet rising demands while safeguarding the values of freedom, dignity, and interdependence. It challenges us to rethink how we define and deliver support, urging collaboration to create systems that prioritize relationships and empower individuals to lead fulfilling lives.
This paper is a must-read for advocates, caregivers, and policymakers seeking to navigate the complexities of developmental disability support systems while preserving humanity and connection.